Amtico vs Karndean: which is the right choice for you?
If you are considering a new vinyl floor you will undoubtedly be taking many different factors into account. Although the design and the overall look of your new floor are really important, in high wear areas of your home or business you will also need to think carefully about durability. On top of this, all home design has a budget and it is important to consider the relative costs of Amtico vs Karndean flooring when making your selection. In this article we explain what each type of floor is and help you decide which is going to be the best flooring solution for your home or business.
Karndean flooring – what exactly is it?
If you are looking for a luxury vinyl floor covering that provides a strong and durable alternative to laminate flooring, Karndean might be exactly what you are after. During manufacture Karndean flooring tiles undergo multiple laminating tempering and lacquering processes to create their trademark five-layer structure and silky finish. The result is an ultra-reliable luxury flooring that is suitable for homes and businesses alike.
So what is Amtico flooring?
Amtico flooring is manufactured in a different way to Karndean flooring. Its distinctive combination of plasticisers, resin and stabilisers are combined at high temperatures under high pressure. The resulting tiles are slim but extremely durable, even in heavy traffic areas of your home or business. Amtico is well known for its striking and expressive design and luxury finishes such as beveled edges.
Karndean or Amtico flooring – what’s the difference?
The first thing to remember here is that both Amtico and Karndean flooring are vinyl-flooring solutions. Vinyl flooring has become very popular over recent years because of its versatility. Forget the boring, flat vinyl designs of the past, advances in manufacture methods mean that vinyl flooring can now rival more traditional wood and stone floors in terms of both durability and style. Whether you are considering Amtico or Karndean, you can be sure that both of these offer high quality, luxury flooring solutions that will stand the test of time and give your home the wow factor.
Although both Karndean and Amtico offer luxurious and versatile flooring solutions, with different manufacturing processes you would be right to expect slightly different products. Whilst Amtico floors have an extremely close resemblance to natural flooring such as wood or stone, Karndean floors generally have a slightly silkier look. Both products are extremely durable and come with lifetime guarantees, which equate to 35 years (it is however worth checking the small print of flooring guarantees for both Karndean and Amtico). These guarantees are transferable, which means that if you decide to sell your property, the flooring guarantee can be carried over to the next owner.
Which is the right luxury vinyl flooring for me?
With two such highly recommended flooring products it is important to carefully consider each option. The Karndean vs Amtico flooring debate is hotly contested but your choice should depend on your own priorities for your home or business. It always pays to take professional advice but the points below will help you make your initial assessments.
Karndean flooring is a great choice if you have a strict budget
Metre for metre Karndean luxury vinyl tiles work out marginally cheaper than Amtico’s budget range. This price difference extends into the higher ranges with Karndean coming in cheaper but with perhaps fewer luxury features.
Amtico flooring has a marginally superior environmental profile
Being kind to the planet isn’t just important for you own peace of mind. If you are a business owner, your environmental footprint can really matter to your customers, and, if you decide to sell your private property, making positive environmental decisions now might really pay off. Environmental certification is complicated and both Amtico and Karndean can claim some level of this, with Karndean using slightly more plasticizers in their manufacture processes. Both companies adhere strictly to current regulations and aim to reduce chemical usage, waste and their carbon footprint.
Both Karndean and Amtico are easy to install
Flooring installation is always best done by the professionals but the easier it is, the better chance you have of the luxury result you are hoping for. The labour and materials requirements for both types of floor are relatively low when compared to other luxury flooring such as stone or wood. Both Amtico and Karndean floors can be laid quickly and easily, giving you the finish you are after with minimum disruption.
Karndean floors are marginally more durable than Amtico floors
There are of course lots of ways to measure durability, and usage will vary according to a number of factors. One way to look at this, particularly in high traffic areas, is to consider resistance to wear. Although both floors have extremely high-rated coatings Karndean just beats Amtico with its K-Guard Surface Protection System. It is worth remembering that different types of flooring from each manufacturer have different levels of resistance and impact resilience.
Trusted and recognised luxury vinyl flooring
If you are looking for luxury vinyl flooring, which has been manufactured to the very highest of standards, both Amtico and Karndean have a lot to offer. Both companies have a good reputation when it comes to customer service and product design, and it is often specific design requirements that swing decisions in one direction or another. If price is your biggest decision factor then Karndean may well be the right choice for you. On the other hand, if Amtico’s additional touches and slightly more natural look suit your design plans, you might be willing to pay just that little bit extra.
One thing is for sure, whichever floor wins your particular Amtico vs Karndean race; you are going to be pleased with the transformation it makes to your home or business. For a combination of luxury and versatility, these flooring manufacturers really can’t be beaten. Whichever flooring option you take, our experienced and knowledgeable team are here to help, and would be happy to discuss a range of options. We offer professional product advice and expert installation, as well as maintenance and aftercare advice. For a free, no-obligation quote, get in touch with us on 020 8959 2629 and talk to our team today.
NATIONAL MUSEUM OF THE ROYAL NAVY – Part of a £1.25m fit out of a major new exhibition for the National Museum of the Royal Navy (NMRM) at Portsmouth Historic Dockyard.
Indigo Flooring were tasked with completing the complicated layout of some 1,500 m2 of Marmoleum flooring with a water jet cut world map inlaid into the floor and Jet cut map of Great Britain vertically installed onto two swing doors, with various hand cut contrasting inlays leading the public to important exhibits throughout.
To see more of our work click here >>>